“Self-defense isn’t just what you felt—it’s what you can prove.”
— Carolle El-Naffy, Esq.
When someone claims self-defense after being charged with assault, it’s not enough to say, “They came at me first.” In the eyes of the law, self-defense is a legal argument with strict criteria—and if you don’t meet them, you could still end up with a criminal conviction.
So, how does the law decide whether self-defense applies in your assault case?
What Is Legally Considered Self-Defense?
Self-defense is the use of reasonable force to protect yourself (or others) from imminent harm. Key word: reasonable. That means your response must be proportionate to the threat.
If someone slaps you and you respond with a knife, the law may say you escalated the violence beyond reason—even if you were scared.
Florida’s Stand Your Ground Law
Florida’s “Stand Your Ground” law goes further than many states. You are not required to retreat if you are in a place where you have a legal right to be. You may use force—even deadly force—if you reasonably believe it is necessary to prevent death or serious bodily harm.
But this law doesn’t give a free pass. If your perception of the threat is questioned, you’ll need strong evidence and an experienced defense attorney to argue your case.
When Self-Defense Applies—and When It Doesn’t
When It Applies:
- You’re faced with a real and immediate threat
- You didn’t provoke the other person
- Your reaction was proportionate
- You were in a place you had the legal right to be
When It Doesn’t Apply:
- You were the aggressor
- You had a chance to retreat safely (in some states)
- You used excessive force
- You acted out of revenge or retaliation
What Evidence Helps Your Case?
- Witness statements backing up your version
- Surveillance footage
- Medical reports or injury photos
- Prior threats from the alleged victim
- A clean record and history of peaceful behavior
Your attorney can help uncover this evidence, file the right motions, and build a narrative the court can support.
Self-Defense Does Not Mean Automatic Dismissal
A self-defense argument doesn’t mean the charges will be dropped. It means your attorney will present a justification for your actions. That justification must be clear, consistent, and persuasive. Without it, the jury could still convict you.
Were you charged with assault but acted in self-defense? Don’t leave your future to chance. Let Carolle El-Naffy evaluate your case and defend your rights under Florida law.
Call Now: (305) 456-7576
By Appointment Only: 75 Valencia Ave • Suite 800 • Coral Gables, FL 33134
Contact Us Online